Jan 02 2007
AP’s Propaganda Artist
Curt at Flopping Aces has been beating the news media over the head with the realization they have been dupes (or much worse) in issuing fake stories from a fake news source in Iraq. I can only salute Curt and others for exposing these lies and the fools or liars who printed them as news. I wanted to make special mention of some analysis done at Confederate Yankee who attempted to validate the stories from the infamous Jamil Hussein, of the Iraq Police, to only find of the 39 or so stories he looked at (out of a total of 60 or so suspect news reports) he could not validate a single story with another news source. Out of 40 stories! Not one! The news media has a lot of explaining to do when they are 100% wrong all the time, and the BEST explanation is they were dupes. I seriously think there should be minimum standards on reporting and punishment for failing to meet those standards. Is this too much to ask for from the press?
It’s looking worse and worse for the AP.
What I wish someone could dig into are these stories by Reuters that every day trot out some number of dead bodies found in Baghdad. They never attribute the reports to a source other than “an interior ministry source” who is never named.
Examples:
December 28: BAGHDAD – Police found 41 bodies in different parts of Baghdad over the past 24 hours, an Interior Ministry source said.
December 27:BAGHDAD – A total of 40 bodies were found, shot dead and most showing signs of torture, in different districts of Baghdad on Tuesday, an Interior Ministry source said.
December 26:BAGHDAD – A total of 40 bodies were found, shot dead and most of them showing signs of torture, on Monday in different districts of Baghdad, an Interior Ministry source said.
December 25:BAGHDAD – A total of 29 bodies were found shot dead, with most showing signs of torture, in different districts of Baghdad on Sunday, an Interior Ministry source said.
Get the picture? Every day this one-sentance report that quotes no specific source, give no locations, provides no information about them (Sunni? Shiite? criminal?) …
I believe that this is a manufactured number reported by someone with an agenda.
Crosspatch, it would be interesting to get some of the articles and see if CENTCOM can confirm those reports.
Stop Linking to AP Stories…
Personally I believe that since WE are the readers of these articles and AP refuses to correct their mistakes, their lies or their faulty information, it is up to US to make, not only our voices, but our displeasure known….
I have long contended that the MSM stories can not be relied on. Everyone quotes them. Washington Journal, for example, reads from them every day. The should all be required to have a disclaimer:
Caution: Read these News stories with skepticism, they have an equal chance of being 100% incorrect.
A couple weeks ago, someone wrote an post that all the numbers were about 53. Same number nearly every day, and none were ever verified.
Beware of anything anybody writes. I try to be truthful, but sometimes I’m wrong also.
I believe that this is a manufactured number reported by someone with an agenda.
http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2006/09/captured_document_ap_employee.html
Sorry, link to last story
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/en/doc/2003-11/30/content_285949.htm
The problem is with those Reuters reports, I can’t find any confirmation. No other agency seems to report those numbers independently though some will quote the Reuters report. Now if the Interior Ministry has a spokesperson, there would be no problem with giving a name and if they issued a daily bulletin or something, there would be no problem with other agencies also getting those numbers.
What I am seeing is a number being reported daily (interestingly, that number is absent or much lower when there are other large Baghdad casualty events such as a car bombing) by only Reuters with no named source.
I believe I know the purpose of the number. It is designed to get aggregate casualty numbers up so that sites such as this one pick they up and tally them. Casualty rates are being used by some sites as some kind of a progress indicator for the war (nevermind that about 80% of Iraq is booming and relatively peaceful) and these numbers are being used to keep the number up. When other casualty events occur, we see the “Baghdad Bodies” number take a drop or completely absent for a day.
It’s bogus. I am going to do a little more research and see if I can identify exactly when the Reuters’ Baghdad Bodies first started showing up.
I quit reading and taking the newspaper two years ago when I realized that even my small town paper echoed the New York Times.
I quit cable TV many years ago and only watched Fox but have even given that up because Fox is getting more leftists. I cannot bear to watch Alan Colmes or Shepherd Smith.
Yea and Shepherd is a good ole Mississippi boy too, don’t know how he got that far astray.
He went to New York City and got in with that bunch.
Oooooops! Turns out Iraqi government was lying about the elusive Jamil Hussein:
BAGHDAD (AP) — The Interior Ministry acknowledged Thursday that an Iraqi police officer whose existence had been denied by the Iraqis and the U.S. military is in fact an active member of the force, and said he now faces arrest for speaking to the media.
Ministry spokesman Brig. Abdul-Karim Khalaf, who had previously denied there was any such police employee as Capt. Jamil Hussein, said in an interview that Hussein is an officer assigned to the Khadra police station, as had been reported by The Associated Press.
The captain, whose full name is Jamil Gholaiem Hussein, was one of the sources for an AP story in late November about the burning and shooting of six people during a sectarian attack at a Sunni mosque.
The U.S. military and the Iraqi Interior Ministry raised the doubts about Hussein in questioning the veracity of the AP’s initial reporting on the incident, and the Iraqi ministry suggested that many news organization were giving a distorted, exaggerated picture of the conflict in Iraq.
Don’t you just hate when that happens and all the propaganda you’ve been spewing turns out to be a leaping helping of bat guano? Michelle Malkin will not be amused!
Final note:
Goshdarn that AP propaganda!